The 10 Best Eyeliner Products For Sensitive Eyes

By Sophia Chartrand Sophia Chartrand has been verified by Muck Rack's editorial team
Published on April 27, 2021

Eyeliner is the one makeup product some women will not leave the house without. Some almost won’t leave the house without it unless their hair is perfect. Finding the right eyeliner is definitely not easy, especially when there are so many to choose from that offer different looks and effects. 

Although eyeliner can sometimes let you down, it isn’t without its debate. They can be too dry, overly dark, wrinkle too easily, or be impregnable enough to ruin any cat-eye. It is impossible to handle life on just one eyeliner. You simply cannot stick to a white eyeliner or lip color if you’re serving a golden child. A black liquid is essential when doing a cat-eye but no red too! If you’re going to go no-makeup, you can accomplish this using the optimal shade of brown… and don’t get us started on the beneficial effects of a good gel liner.


If you’re in a hurry, here are our top 3 quick picks for the Best Eyeliner of 2021


Criteria for Choosing the Best Eyeliner

The liner should be used only on the top lid for a lifted, youthful appearance. Most stylists recommend using a lighter color on the bottom lash line, which gives you the same definition as the top lashes but is also softer and more flattering.

Is it bad to wear eyeliner every day?

Not at all, as long as it is applied correctly. The importance of applying eyeliner every day will give you a defined, cool look every day. Make sure not to skip your facial cleansing routine, regardless of whether or not you wear make-up. 

Is it bad to put eyeliner on your waterline?

It is safe if you’re using the right product. Your first concern is whether eyeliner is okay for the waterline. Because the eyes are a sensitive area, it’s understandable that the application of eyeliner so close to the eye could irritate them. 

There are many products available that can fulfill all eyeliner needs, but finding the right one can be a difficult process and an expensive one, so we compiled a list of the best available eyeliners that are being sold via Amazon. Our criteria for choosing the best eyeliners include ones that do not run or smudge the eyes, as well as their durability and longevity (aka. How long they last).


The 10 of Best Eyeliner of 2021

MAYBELLINE Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner

Introducing the liquid liner with no skips, gaps, and pain; thanks to the easy brush tip this liquid liner glides on smoothly and shapes to your eye. It lasts up to 24 hours with intense, long-lasting color that doesn’t smudge; It has a flex tip brush that gives optimal control with easy application. They also have eyeshadows, eyeliners, brows, and mascara collections designed to transform your look with subtle lines, smokey vibes, classic tones, or a pop of color. Besides foundations, concealers, and bronzers, Maybelline’s full line of makeup includes mascaras, eyebrow pencils, eyeliners, and lipstick.

PROS
  • No smudging
  • The price is worth its value
  • It provides a safe formula for sensitive eyes
  • The brush tip works best for precision liner into the inner rim and corner of the eyes
CONS
  • One customer reports that there is an uneven liquid distribution 
  • One customer reports that the formula requires 2-3 strokes for a full black streak

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Liner Pencil

A line and the defined eye is just a twist away with this eyeliner pen. This eyeliner glides on easily & stays put all day through heat & humidity, no smudged eyeliner here! With no sad bleeding eyeliner with the Retractable Eye Pencil, any eyeliner look is possible. The intense pigment covers like a liquid eyeliner while its creamy formula holds for hours. No need to sharpen just twist up and apply for a winged-out eyeliner look. No makeup they offer is tested on animals. All of their makeup is certified cruelty-free by PETA.

PROS
  • It is waterproof
  • It is non-cruelty tested
  • The price is worth its value
  • It is smooth and smudge-proof
CONS
  • One customer reports that the pen didn’t bring out a lot of color

Artisan L’uxe Beauty Velvet Jumbo Eyeliner Pencil

Providing an incredible smokey, smoldering look while keeping eyes softly centered, this Velvet Eyeliner Pencil is crafted in jumbo size, dome shape, and finely milled silk powder. This pencil eyeliner was invented by makeup artist Sue Devitt, designed to withstand tough beauty conditions under pressure, but you don’t have to be a celebrity to enjoy those benefits! Take the eyeliner game to the next level with this smudge-proof, water-resistant eyeliner that glides over the lid with ease. Meanwhile, the built-in smudge tip makes it easy to blend. Infused with organic sunflower seed oil and chamomile extract, age-defying ceramides rejuvenate and firm skin. Hyaluronic acid nourishes the delicate eye area.

PROS
  • It is easy to use 
  • The price is worth its value
  • Provides a nice creamy coverage on the eye 
  • One customer reports that the pencil does not extend and that the tip can only be sharpened (good/bad)
CONS
  • One customer reports that the pencil does not extend and that the tip can only be sharpened (good/bad)

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Matte Liquid Eyeliner

With this Matte Liquid Liner, you can draw wing eyeliner with expert precision like an amazing makeup artist. This eyeliner comes with an ultra-fine precision brush tip that allows for precision when drawing the thickest to thinnest lines, while the matte black formula provides elegant coverage that is both matte and smudge-proof. You can find more eye makeup products at NYX Professional Makeup to complete your look, including palettes for eyeshadow, eyeliner, concealer, setting sprays, and eyebrow products. As a cruelty-free brand, they don’t test any of our makeup products on animals, as all of their products are certified and recognized by PETA as cruelty-free.

PROS
  • It stays dry all-day 
  • The price is worth its value
  • It includes a precision brush 
CONS
  • One customer reports that the brush is a little too thick

stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

This liquid eyeliner is the perfect waterproof formula with an ultra-thin tip! With this liner, you can line and define, as you define your lashes with quick, but accurate strokes. This formula glides on with ease, dries quickly, and won’t smudge or run day into night. The regular size eyeliner may be easier when you are rushing to get ready because you can do it in a couple of swipes. It is truly waterproof, but it can be taken off easily with soap and water or a proper oil-based remover. It does not smear and you can apply multiple layers on your eyelids to achieve a fashionable look.

PROS
  • The price is worth its value
  • It comes with a super-fine tip
  • It is long-lasting and waterproof
CONS
  • One customer reports that the eyeliner they received was dried out

Rimmel Exaggerate Eyeliner Definer

Embrace your inner Londoner with the Exaggerate Blackest Black Waterproof Eye Definer so you can look like you’ve got London on your side when you’re out and about. With the new innovative formula that provides an intense finish, you can achieve a smoky eye look regardless of whether you are out for business or pleasure. Use bold lines to highlight eyes in just one stroke. The formula is waterproof and color-intense for long-lasting wear. The Exaggerate Eye Definer is the perfect mainstay of any eyewear collection and a great gift for women who want to achieve the London look. Rimmel’s products are innovative and fashion-forward. Versatile and accessible. They are designed to challenge and encourage individuals to experiment and express themselves.

PROS
  • It is waterproof
  • The application is smooth
  • The price is worth its value
  • Provides a great color saturation
CONS
  • One customer reports that they received an eyeliner that was tampered with

L’Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Never Fail Original Mechanical Pencil Eyeliner

This creamy, rich eye pencil glides on smoothly and stays on all day! It features a built-in sharpener for convenient sharpening, which makes it easy to do everything you need to do with your eyes, including creating your own designs. You can use the built-in sharpener for the best results; smudge to ensure the pencil tip is smooth, and create versatile eye looks. In addition to extensive foundations, concealers and highlighters, brow pencils, eyeshadow palettes, lipsticks, and foundations, L’Oreal Paris makeup helps you create the look you want. Make sure you have the perfect makeup eye look with their collection of EYE makeup products. Get the perfect look with their voluminous mascara, achieve flawless lines with smudge-proof eyeliner, define your brows, and discover the eye shadow palette with shades created for every eye color.

PROS
  • The eyeliner easily glides on 
  • Comes in an awesome color
  • It is super dark on the waterline
  • It comes with a pencil sharpener
CONS
  • One customer reports that the pencil sharpener did not work when they received the eyeliner

Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner

This waterproof eyeliner’s ultra-fine tip delivers defined, precise lines that stay on for hours with whatever look you are trying to achieve. Make eyes look their best with long-lasting color that isn’t smudged –  it is dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested, fragrance-free, making it perfect for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes. You can use Maybelline’s eyeshadow, eyeliner, brows, and mascara collections to transform your look with subtle lines, smokey vibes, custom brow looks, or a pop of color.

PROS
  • The price is worth its value 
  • Comes in a variety of colors
  • The application process is smooth
CONS
  • One customer reports that the eyeliner smudges easily 

Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil

You can enhance the look of your eyes with rich, luminous color by applying a .01-ounce pencil of Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Makeup. The eyeliner pencil is formulated with nourishing olive oil and rainforest shea butter, which makes it apply smoothly and last all day without fading or smudging. In addition to a built-in pencil-sharpening system for precision makeup application, you will receive a built-in contoured smudger for framing an elegant soft, blended, smoky eye. These nourishing eyeliners come in several beautiful shades and can be easily removed with the Neutrogena Makeup Remover or complemented by any Neutrogena Mascara. Skin dermatologists and ophthalmologists have also tested the eye makeup to show it was gentle and safe for those with sensitive eyes and those who wear contact lenses.

PROS
  • Comes with a variety of colors
  • The application process is smooth
  • It works best with hypoallergenic issues (aka. Sensitive eyes)
CONS
  • One customer reports that it is impossible to keep the eyeliner sharp 

20-Colors Eyeliner Pencil Set

The newest design of colored mechanical pencil eyeliners delivers a vivid sense of color to your eye designs, not just a black line in the corner, different from the classic black and brown. There are 20 bright colors of strong shades in this collection that will make your eyes pop, long-lasting and fade-resistant. Apply it to your waterlines, inner corners & entire eyelids for a true one-of-a-kind look. There is no fading, water-resistant, sweat-proof, water-resistant formula with a smooth, natural feel ensures smooth, perfect lines for up to 24 hours. In addition, it glides on smoothly and precisely, creates the perfect makeup in just a simple turn. With this unique package, this would be the perfect gift to your friends, besties, and family, making it ideal for parties, weddings, concerts, and more!

PROS
  • They are easy to use
  • The price is worth its value
  • Comes with a variety of fun colors to choose from
CONS
  • One customer reports that there are a lot of defects with the various color pencils

In Conclusion 

We hope you found the perfect eyeliner that suits your needs. You may want to go with a pencil or marker if you’re a newbie to eyeliner. On the other hand, if you like to play it safe but still desire a dramatic cat-eye, you might enjoy grabbing a liquid or gel formula. Either way, your eyes will still be vibrant as ever!


Other Products You May Need

We hope you enjoy these products! But keep in mind, Grit Daily might take a small commission on the items recommended here—but that doesn’t mean we don’t believe in them. We only recommend products that we would buy or use ourselves, so don’t be wary of our suggestions. 

By Sophia Chartrand Sophia Chartrand has been verified by Muck Rack's editorial team

Journalist verified by Muck Rack verified

Sophia Chartrand is an Affiliate Content Contributor here at Grit Daily, covering affiliate product reviews. Raised in the beautiful mountains of Park City, Utah, she dominates the music industry as a freelance music journalist and publicist, as well as currently working her way up to artist management and production herself. While she's not carrying too much on her plate, you can find her hiking, cooking, or adventuring into the unknown.

Read more

More articles by Sophia Chartrand


Sophia Chartrand Sophia Chartrand has been verified by Muck Rack's editorial team
on November 18, 2021

The 11 Sexiest Bell Bottom Styles Of The Year

Sophia Chartrand Sophia Chartrand has been verified by Muck Rack's editorial team
on November 10, 2021

Here Are The 9 Top Among Us Plushes Of 2021

Sophia Chartrand Sophia Chartrand has been verified by Muck Rack's editorial team
on November 9, 2021

The 8 Most Beautiful Hematite Rings Your Fingers Need

Sophia Chartrand Sophia Chartrand has been verified by Muck Rack's editorial team
on November 5, 2021

The 10 Most Eloquent Sunset Projector Lamps Of 2021

More GD News