The Top 10 Real Estate Agents in Wisconsin for 2024

By Spencer Hulse Spencer Hulse has been verified by Muck Rack's editorial team
Published on February 19, 2024

In the dynamic world of real estate, finding the right agent is pivotal for navigating the market’s complexities, whether you’re buying or selling property. With its diverse real estate landscape, from bustling city properties to serene lakeside retreats, Wisconsin offers unique opportunities and challenges. This is where the expertise of the top real estate agents in Wisconsin comes into play, guiding clients through transactions with unparalleled local knowledge and negotiation skills. Our comprehensive guide to the top 10 real estate agents in Wisconsin connects buyers and sellers with the best professionals in the industry, ensuring a smooth and successful real estate experience.

The importance of choosing a skilled real estate agent cannot be overstated, especially in a market as varied as Wisconsin’s. The top real estate agents in Wisconsin are not just facilitators of transactions; they are trusted advisors who understand the intricacies of the market, from current listing prices to the nuances of different neighborhoods. These agents stand out for their ability to match clients with their ideal properties, proven track records of successful deals, and commitment to exceptional service. Our list includes agents who excel in various real estate transactions, including luxury homes, commercial properties, and everything in between.

Leveraging local expertise and a deep understanding of market trends, the top real estate agents in Wisconsin offer invaluable assistance to those looking to invest in the state’s real estate. By highlighting the achievements and specialties of these elite professionals, our guide aims to demystify the process of buying or selling property in Wisconsin. Whether you’re searching for a spacious family home in a suburban neighborhood, a trendy apartment in the heart of a bustling city, or a peaceful getaway by the lake, the agents featured in our top 10 list have the skills, knowledge, and experience to make your real estate dreams a reality.


1. Carrie Powell

Carrie Powell

Carrie Powell, a distinguished Realtor at Century 21 Ace Realty in Wisconsin, has over a decade of experience in real estate and 25-plus years in sales and marketing. As a result, she has built her business entirely on referrals and has consistently received the Centurion, Masters Diamond, and Quality Service Awards.

Carrie’s client-first attitude is evident in her dedication to understanding and addressing their needs. She is known for her patience, effective communication, and attention to detail. Her knowledge of the Fox Cities’ real estate market and negotiation, organization and management skills ensure her clients achieve their goals with positive, low-hassle outcomes.

In addition to her sales prowess, Carrie is a trusted mentor and coach to new agents, sharing her knowledge and insights to elevate the industry. Her approach to listings is comprehensive, involving preparation, decluttering, cleaning, and staging to enhance property appeal, often going above and beyond by providing personal assistance.

In 2024, Carrie embarks on a new chapter, partnering with her daughter, Grace Powell, to form a team. This move promises to enhance the services offered to her clients, combining Carrie’s vast experience with Grace’s fresh perspective and marketing acumen. Together, they represent a dynamic force in Wisconsin’s real estate market.


2. Michael Fitzpatrick

Michael Fitzpatrick

Michael Fitzpatrick, a dedicated Realtor at Fitz Listings LLC within First Weber Realtors, stands out as a beacon of expertise in Wisconsin’s real estate landscape. Hailing from Oconomowoc, Michael’s journey reflects a unique blend of entrepreneurial spirit and unwavering tenacity.

His passion for community service and business acumen emerged early, evolving from selling lemonade to running a wedding DJ company, Audio Trio DJ Service. While studying business at the University of Wisconsin, Whitewater, Michael established a nationwide t-shirt-selling company. Michael’s impact has been profound since launching his real estate career in 2019. He rose swiftly, reaching the top 20% in his office as part of Wisconsin’s leading brokerage.

Michael streamlines the real estate process, sparing clients from unnecessary complexities. In a low-inventory market, his buyers have never lost on more than three offers, a stark contrast to competitors. Notably, all his listings have sold at or above their recommended prices.

In a challenging year for real estate, Michael’s resilience and strategic approach resulted in a stellar performance, adeptly navigating a market with 20% fewer available homes in 2023. His ability to secure off-market deals for buyers and seamlessly collaborate within a top brokerage gives him a unique edge in the industry.

With integrity at his core, Michael Fitzpatrick crafts ethical and transparent real estate dealings for the people of southeast Wisconsin.


3. Andrea Lindemann

Andrea Lindemann

Andrea Lindemann, affectionately known by many as Dre, stands out as a dedicated Real Estate Agent at CENTURY 21 Affiliated in Wisconsin with a genuine passion for real estate. She considers it both a career and her favorite hobby, putting enthusiasm, relatability, and tenacity at the core of her approach. Her commitment to making real estate dreams come true is evident through her impressive accolades, including the Masters Emerald award in 2021 and the Masters Ruby and Quality Service Producer awards in 2020. 

Andrea is an Accredited Buyer Representative with nine years of experience, specializing in various property types, from houses and condos to commercial spaces and land across 24 locations, including Beaver Dam and Kenosha. Praised for her in-depth knowledge, patience, and ability to exceed expectations, Andrea has earned glowing testimonials from clients who value her comprehensive support throughout the buying and selling process. Her unwavering dedication and expertise make her a highly recommended agent for anyone looking to navigate the real estate market in South Central Wisconsin.


4. Heather Gossen

Heather Gossen, an esteemed Realtor and Owner Partner at Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Fox Cities Realty in Wisconsin, exemplifies the epitome of real estate excellence.

With over 18 years of combined experience in real estate sales, marketing, and service, Heather stands out in the industry. She expresses gratitude throughout the process, not just at closing, including sending personalized gifts to clients even before the first meeting.

Heather’s expertise spans various sectors, including first-time home buying, new construction, waterfront properties, foreclosures, investments, and relocation in Appleton, Neenah, Menasha, DePere, Green Bay, and the greater Fox Valley. At her core is honesty, integrity, and persistence.

Highlights of Heather’s career include co-founding Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Fox Cities Realty and establishing The Gifted Agent™, where she imparts her knowledge to other Realtors, lenders, and sales professionals. Her accolades include being a President’s Circle Gold achiever and holding ABR and GRI certifications.

Heather redefines the client-agent relationship, adding a personal touch to each transaction. Adhering to her ‘FOREVER Agent’ philosophy, she is a lifelong client advocate and partner. This holistic and empathetic approach to real estate makes her a prime candidate for those seeking a genuine, client-focused professional.


5. Josh Brost

Josh Brost

Josh Brost, an accomplished REALTOR® at Keller Williams Madison West Realty in Wisconsin, brings four years of real estate prowess, aiding over 60 clients in successful transactions. Hailing from Portage, Wisconsin, and armed with a BBA in Marketing and Economics from the University of Wisconsin – Oshkosh, Josh’s journey began with joining The Stark Team at Keller Williams Green Bay amid recent global challenges.

Setting himself apart, Josh embraces cutting-edge technology, utilizing social media and video content to offer a modern, adaptable real estate experience. His client-focused approach has a personal touch that includes responsiveness and tailored marketing strategies. 

Josh transitioned to full-time real estate upon graduating college in 2021, solidifying his position as one of Keller Williams Madison West Realty’s top producers the following year. He achieved the 2022 Leadership Excellence Award and assumed the role of Vice President at Keller Williams Young Professionals Wisconsin Chapter. In 2023, Josh’s social media acumen earned him a spot as a Social Media Panelist Member at Keller Williams Fox Cities Mega Agent Panel.

Having purchased his first home at 24, Josh epitomizes youthful dedication, making him an ideal choice for those seeking a genuine, knowledgeable, and community-connected real estate professional in Wisconsin.


6. Ana Juarez

Ana Juarez

Ana Juarez, a distinguished Realtor at HomePoint Real Estate in Wisconsin, has crafted an admirable career through integrity, hard work, and exceptional service. With a Bachelor’s degree in Business Administration and Marketing, Ana brings knowledge and innovative marketing strategies to the table, ensuring her clients receive insightful guidance in the ever-evolving Central Wisconsin real estate market.

Growing up in a large family, Ana developed her understanding of diverse personalities, which she applies to her real estate endeavors. Her fluency in Spanish and extensive network of international connections enable her to serve a broad clientele effectively. Ana is known for her ability to negotiate adeptly, communicate exceptionally, and commit wholeheartedly to exceeding client expectations.

Ana’s unique approach to real estate includes respect, integrity, and a touch of humor. This ethos, combined with her tech-savviness and continuous professional development, evidenced by her participation in prestigious business conferences worldwide, sets her apart in the industry.

Focusing on personalized service, financial clarity for buyers, and strategic marketing for sellers, Ana Juarez is the preferred choice for many in the Central Wisconsin real estate market. Her company similarly sets a shining example, with inclusivity and mutual support at its heart.


7. Broc Fleischer

Broc Fleischer

Broc Fleischer, a distinguished Broker/Agent at Homestead Realty Inc. in Wisconsin, stands out in the competitive real estate landscape. With his commitment to providing top-notch expertise in the local market, Broc has built a reputation for delivering exceptional results. He brings a personal touch to his work, emphasizing honesty, trustworthiness, and in-depth knowledge of real estate dynamics. 

Broc’s dedication extends beyond finding dream homes or securing the best offers; he guides his clients through every step, ensuring a seamless and informed buying or selling experience. Moreover, Broc takes a proactive approach in a fast-paced market. His background as a lender for over two decades enriches his insight into various mortgage options, benefiting his clients.

A Certified Real Estate Negotiator, Broc’s strategic offer writing leads to higher acceptance rates, minimizing the need for multiple offers. His accolades include being a consistent sales leader, earning the Best of Zillow recognition, and holding the C.R.E.N. certification.

Broc’s multifaceted expertise streamlines the transaction process, ensuring buyers’ and sellers’ efficiency and satisfaction. His dedication to working around the clock and charging lower fees than competitors saves his clients thousands of dollars and makes him a top-performing agent.


8. Stacey Hennessey

Stacey Hennessey

Stacey Hennessey, a distinguished Broker Associate at CENTURY 21 Affiliated in Wisconsin, has an impressive track record in the real estate industry. 

With a license as a Broker Associate and numerous accreditations such as Accredited Buyer Representative, Certified Residential Specialist, and Seniors Residential Specialist, Stacey has proven her expertise across the Fox Cities Area. Her commitment to facilitating stress-free transitions for buyers and sellers is the cornerstone of her approach. 

Navigating complexities from offer to closing, Stacey showcases her skills as a negotiator and a mediator among various stakeholders. Her access to skilled tradespeople also ensures the swift resolution of any inspection issues to the satisfaction of her clients.

Stacey Hennessey & Co has garnered industry accolades, including the Century 21 President’s Award for Top Quality Service and Grand Centurion Production, with over $370m in properties sold since 2010. Its focus on mastering real estate trends and providing exceptional customer service has earned it a top spot among Century 21 Global Producers and the trust and recommendations of its clients.


9. Gino Morales

Gino Morales

Gino Morales, co-founder of the Golden Legacy Group in Wisconsin, is a distinguished figure in the real estate industry, celebrated for his innovative approach to buying and selling homes. 

With over 150 families assisted on their real estate journeys, Gino’s prowess extends beyond traditional methods; he is a trailblazer in employing social media and marketing strategies to revolutionize how homes are marketed and sold. As a 2X ICON Agent with eXp Realty and a Marketing Director for eXp Latino, his contributions have been instrumental in mentoring hundreds of agents, empowering them to leverage digital platforms for enhanced visibility and success.

Gino and his wife, Eloisa, have garnered recognition as an ICON power couple, earning accolades for their outstanding performance and contribution to the real estate sector. Their venture, Golden Legacy Group, operates globally, offering virtual support and strategic partnerships to expand their impact. 

As a first-generation Hispanic realtor, Gino’s involvement with eXp Latino and NAHREP underscores his commitment to community and professional excellence. Gino Morales is a paragon of innovation, dedication, and success in the real estate and entrepreneurial landscape, inspiring others to embrace modern marketing techniques to achieve their goals.


10. Sara Capecchi

Sara Capecchi

Sara Capecchi, a visionary Realtor with eXp Realty in Wisconsin, has been making waves in the real estate industry since her bold entrance in 2016. With a passion for housing and design, she quickly became an example of success, helping 25 families find their dream homes in her debut year alone. Sara’s integrity, seamless communication, and boundless enthusiasm define the ethos of Capecchi and Company, making every client interaction a joyous journey toward homeownership.

Under Sara’s leadership, her team has mastered creating memorable, efficient real estate experiences, utilizing cutting-edge marketing, professional staging, and extensive networking to ensure they meet every client’s need with expertise. Sara’s innovative approach has earned her features in Hudson Neighbors magazine and The American Dream TV, with listings even showing the potential to go viral.

Residing in Hudson, WI with her husband and their two sons, Sara’s commitment to clients parallels her devotion at home. Whether buying or selling, Sara Capecchi and her team offer comprehensive support, from complimentary staging to a step-by-step guide through the real estate process, ensuring an enjoyable transition to the next home adventure.


Our comprehensive guide connects buyers and sellers with the best professionals in the industry, ensuring a smooth and successful real estate experience. Our list includes agents who excel in various real estate transactions, including luxury homes, commercial properties, and everything in between. By leveraging local expertise and a deep understanding of market trends, the top real estate agents in Wisconsin offer invaluable assistance to those looking to invest in the state’s real estate. Whether you’re searching for a spacious family home in a suburban neighborhood, a trendy apartment in the heart of a bustling city, or a peaceful getaway by the lake, the agents featured in our top 10 list have the skills, knowledge, and experience to make your real estate dreams a reality. Trust the experts and choose one of the top 10 real estate agents in Wisconsin for 2024.

By Spencer Hulse Spencer Hulse has been verified by Muck Rack's editorial team

Spencer Hulse is the Editorial Director at Grit Daily. He is responsible for overseeing other editors and writers, day-to-day operations, and covering breaking news.

Read more

More GD News