Building Customer Loyalty in E-Commerce: 6 Tips from Marketing Leaders

By Greg Grzesiak Greg Grzesiak has been verified by Muck Rack's editorial team
Published on February 9, 2024

In the fast-paced world of e-commerce, cultivating customer loyalty is more crucial than ever. We’ve gathered insights from six industry experts, including CEOs and a digital marketing manager, to share their strategies. From creating value beyond transactions to celebrating customer values with discounts, discover how these professionals are successfully engaging and retaining customers through innovative loyalty initiatives.

  • Create Value Beyond Transactions
  • Be Interactive with Social Engagement
  • Personalize Experiences to Foster VIP Loyalty
  • Shape Retention with Customer Feedback
  • Extend the Buying Journey for Loyalty
  • Celebrate Customer Values with Discounts

Create Value Beyond Transactions

One highly effective strategy is to implement a loyalty program that goes beyond just transactional rewards. The key is to make customers feel valued and part of a community.

A stellar example of this is Sephora’s Beauty Insider Program. This program is more than just a point-reward system; it’s an immersive experience. Members earn points not just for purchases but for engaging with the brand—like participating in beauty classes and events. The genius of this program lies in its tiered system (Insider, VIB, Rouge), which creates a sense of exclusivity and aspiration. As customers move up tiers, they unlock more personalized and valuable rewards, such as early access to products, exclusive events, and even free makeovers.

This program has been incredibly successful in fostering a strong emotional connection with customers. It taps into what their clientele value the most—exclusivity, personalization, and a sense of belonging in the beauty community. By offering these unique experiences and rewards, Sephora has not just retained customers but turned them into brand advocates. This approach of integrating emotional and experiential rewards with a traditional loyalty program can be a powerful blueprint for e-commerce businesses aiming to enhance customer loyalty.

Bruno GavinoBruno Gavino
Founder, CEO, CodeDesign

Be Interactive with Social Engagement

Working at this Australian online refurbished phone seller, we rolled out a loyalty program that was a real game-changer.

Customers received points for every dollar they spent, so if they spent 50 dollars, they got 50 points. We wanted to make the whole experience more interactive, so we encouraged them to share their purchases on social media. For every platform they shared on—like Facebook, Instagram, or Twitter—they received 100 points. That’s up to 300 points for just a few clicks.

Next, we wanted to ensure the maximum number of people would write reviews on different platforms. We asked them to leave their thoughts about their purchases on websites like Trustpilot or, and for every review, they earned another 100 points. And for those who went the extra mile and sent us a video testimonial, we gave them a whopping 200 points. These videos were not just fun; they were gold for us in terms of genuine customer feedback.

But the real cherry on top was the birthday treat. On their special day, customers received a huge 40% off on their purchase and an additional 150 points as a birthday gift from us.

This whole approach made our customers feel valued and engaged. They weren’t just earning points; they were part of a community, sharing, talking, and celebrating with us. It was this sense of belonging that kept them coming back, proving that sometimes, it’s the little things that count the most in building lasting customer relationships.

Abdullah ArifAbdullah Arif
Digital Marketing Manager, Cloudways

Personalize Experiences to Foster VIP Loyalty

At Startup House, we believe that cultivating customer loyalty in the competitive e-commerce landscape requires a combination of personalized experiences, exceptional customer service, and innovative loyalty programs.

One example of a successful loyalty initiative is our “VIP Club.” By offering exclusive perks such as early access to new products, personalized recommendations, and special discounts, we create a sense of exclusivity and make our customers feel valued.

Additionally, we actively engage with our customers through social media, responding to their comments and inquiries promptly. This personalized approach helps us build strong relationships with our customers, fostering loyalty and repeat business.

Alex StasiakAlex Stasiak
CEO & Founder, Startup House

Shape Retention with Customer Feedback

To cultivate loyalty, we place a strong emphasis on the customer feedback loop. We actively encourage and respond to customer feedback, using it to shape our services. A key initiative in this regard has been our “Customer Voice” program, where we regularly survey customers and implement changes based on their input.

This program has been instrumental in retaining customers, as they see their suggestions being valued and acted upon, fostering a sense of ownership and loyalty toward the brand.

Ian SellsIan Sells
CEO, Million Dollar Sellers

Extend the Buying Journey for Loyalty

I’m the director at Bobo Digital, and we’re working with a florist in Adelaide. In the flower industry, purchase decisions are made in a moment, often within 20 minutes, and customers tend to not think about flowers again for a year. Brand loyalty is a real challenge; as a result, people forget.

To address this and build brand loyalty, we try to extend the buying journey. We send text updates at each step: order confirmation, flowers being picked, and delivery. After delivery, we encourage reviews to build positive brand associations. Finally, we’ve introduced a new initiative: sending a thank-you card and a discount for the next order to the gift-giver. This keeps our brand top of mind for their next special occasion.

As a result of this, we have seen sales double from returning users and often increase the number of times people purchase flowers in the year.

Ben DebonoBen Debono
Director, Bobo Digital

Celebrate Customer Values with Discounts

Loyalty starts with understanding what the customer values and being in celebration of those values.

When we sell yarn, we also encourage customers to share their creations on dedicated social media pages. Sharing that finished project gives them a 10% discount on their next yarn purchase. This not only creates a sense of community and celebrates our customers’ creativity; it holds real-world value for them.

Fungai MbokoFungai Mboko
E-Commerce Account Manager, Notions Marketing

Related Articles

By Greg Grzesiak Greg Grzesiak has been verified by Muck Rack's editorial team

Greg Grzesiak is an Entrepreneur-In-Residence and Columnist at Grit Daily. As CEO of Grzesiak Growth LLC, Greg dedicates his time to helping CEOs influencers and entrepreneurs make the appearances that will grow their following in their reach globally. Over the years he has built strong partnerships with high profile educators and influencers in Youtube and traditional finance space. Greg is a University of Florida graduate with years of experience in marketing and journalism.

Read more

More GD News